How the pollsters fared in Florida

From left to right: GOP gubernatorial hopefulls Bill McCollum and Rick Scott; and Democratic U.S. Senate candidates Kendrick Meek and Jeff Greene

And the polling winner is: Public Policy Polling. No more calling them Rasmussen for Democrats, folks. PPP came the closest to calling the results last night, and unlike Mason-Dixon and Quinnipiac, they didn’t raise McCollum’s hopes cruelly (although QP did come back to reality at the end.) Results of the most recent polling by pollster:

GOP Gov – TH/MD/QP/PPP/QP2/ACTUAL
Rick Scott – 42 / 30 / 35 /47 / 39 / 46.4
Bill McCollum – 32 / 34 / 44 /40 / 35 / 43.5
Mike McCalister – – /– /– / / – / 10.1

Dem Sen – TH/MD/QP/PPP / QP / ACTUAL
Jeff Greene – 35  /26 /28 /27 / 39 / 31.0
Kendrick Meek – 31  / 40 / 35 / 51 / 29 / 57.5
Maurice Ferré – 4 / — /6 / 4 / – / 4.9
Glenn Burkett — – / — / — / — / 6.5

… which of course makes the following very alarming for Democrats:

Democrats will get their stronger candidate if Kendrick Meek wins the Florida Senate primary tonight as expected- but the biggest winner coming out of the primary may be Marco Rubio. PPP finds he would begin the general election in the lead at 40%, followed by Charlie Crist at 32%, and Meek at 17%. If Jeff Greene were somehow able to pull off the upset tonight it would be much closer with Rubio at 37%, Crist at 36%, and Greene at only 13%.

PPP’s last poll of the race in mid-July found Crist in the lead at 35% to 29% for Rubio and 17% for Meek. Two major developments have shifted the race in Rubio’s direction though. The first is that Democrats are now going for Meek 39-38 where before they were going for Crist 44-35. As Democrats have gotten to know Meek over the course of the primary campaign they’ve generally decided they like him and that’s cut into Crist’s support for the general election.

The other big difference is that many Republican voters have moved off the fence and they’ve almost universally moved into the Rubio column. Where Rubio had a 54-23 lead with GOP voters in July, it’s now increased to 69-20. Many Republicans were up in the air between Crist and Rubio previously but whatever they’ve seen over the last month has moved them more firmly into the Rubio column.

Crist’s support continues to show an awkward balance that may ultimately make victory for him impossible. 57% of those planning to vote for him if Meek is the nominee think he should caucus with the Democrats in the Senate if elected while 28% think he should side with the Republicans. He’s more likely to find the additional support he needs to get elected from Democrats than Republicans, but can he do that without losing the 20% of Republicans who are still with him? Whether he finds a way to thread that needle or not will probably determine his fate.

Now the caveat, of course, is that PPP conducted this poll before the primary results were known. The real key, for Kendrick Meek and for Charlie Crist, is where each of them stands in the first set of polls to come out taking Tuesday’s results into account. If Meek is still in the teens in those polls, we’re looking at a race where he scores just well enough to elect Marco Rubio. At that point, it will be gut check time for Florida Democrats.

This entry was posted in Charlie Crist, Elections, Florida, Kendrick Meek, Marco Rubio, People, Politics, Polls and tagged , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

4 Responses to How the pollsters fared in Florida

  1. VJ says:

    I noticed during the 2008 presidential campaign, PPP was always the most accurate of all the pollsters. Rasmussen was always off by several percentage points, generally in favor of republican candidates as usual.

  2. Rupert says:

    Someone named Mike McAlister is listed as receiving 10.1% of the Republican vote. I never heard of the guy, but maybe he was the “vote for me if you’re sick of negative campaigning” candidate??

  3. Flo says:

    FYI
    “McCalister’s name will be on Florida’s GOP primary ballot on Aug. 24th. He is a retired U. S. Army Colonel who worked at CentCom; holds a PhD and MBA and taught in several colleges, and operates a business growing palm trees in Plant City. Judging from his resume, he is eminently qualified to lead a growing state of more than 15 million residents.”

  4. Pingback: Robot poll: Rubio (R) 40%, Crist (I) 30%, Meek (D) 21% : The Reid Report

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>